When a headache hides a bigger mystery

The link between tension pain and autonomic symptoms

For many people, tension-type headaches are a quiet companion to everyday life - a mild, throbbing discomfort that more often bothers than causes serious concern. Unlike migraines, they rarely draw attention and even less frequently arouse scientific interest. But what if these seemingly harmless ailments hide secrets that could change our understanding of chronic headaches?

Research led by Marcin Straburzynski, MD, and Marta Waliszewska-Prosół, MD, of a team of Polish scientists, published in the Wroclaw  Medical University journal "Dental and Medical Problems", uncovers an unexpected fact: cranial autonomic symptoms (CAS), until now mainly attributed to migraines and trigeminal autonomic headaches (TAC), can also occur in tension-type headaches (TTH). This discovery could have important implications for patients struggling with this common but unexplored condition.

What are cranial autonomic symptoms?

Imagine a headache accompanied by tears from the eyes, a blocked nose, or even facial sweating. At first glance, such symptoms may seem atypical for an ordinary headache, right? These are precisely cranial autonomic symptoms — CAS. They are usually associated with migraines or rare but intense trigeminal autonomic headaches (TACs). Moreover, their nature can resemble symptoms of sinus infections or eye irritation, leading to misdiagnoses.

As Dr. Straburzynski explains, these symptoms may result from the trigeminal-autonomic reflex, which evolved to protect our eyes and noses.

"When something enters the eye or nose, the trigeminal nerve is stimulated, triggering autonomic reactions such as tearing or swelling of the mucous membrane. A similar mechanism may be at work for headaches, including TTH" explains the study's author.

Dr Marcin Straburzynski, the President of the Warmia and Mazury Regional Branch of the Polish College of General Practitioners.

Dr Marcin Straburzynski, the President of the Warmia and Mazury Regional Branch of the Polish College of General Practitioners.

What makes the findings even more surprising is that these characteristic symptoms, thought to be the domain of more severe headaches, also occur in tension-type headaches. This finding is particularly significant given that tension-type headaches are the most common type of headache in the world, affecting thousands of people every day.

Analysis of “Migraine in Poland”

A team of researchers has analyzed data collected from more than 3,000 participants in the "Migraine in Poland" survey, a large-scale study designed to examine the characteristics and effects of different headaches in the Polish population. The study was initiated by Marta Waliszewska-Prosół, MD, of the Department of Neurology at the Wroclaw Medical University. Participants were recruited through social media, media advertisements, and collaboration with the medical and academic communities, allowing for one of the most comprehensive analyses of its kind.

In this large group, 166 individuals met the criteria for frequent episodic tension-type headache (eTTH), one of the most common types of headache. This variant of the condition is characterized by regular episodes that do not reach the intensity of chronic forms, making them relatively easy for patients and doctors to overlook or underestimate. Symptoms are often mild to moderate, and the pain itself is compressive without the pulsation or aggravation typical of migraines when exposed to physical activity.

The study also explored the demographic and clinical characteristics of the participants. The results indicate that most of those with eTTH are middle-aged women, consistent with general epidemiological trends for headaches. In addition, the analysis considered the co-occurrence of other symptoms, such as allodynia, a condition in which stimuli that are usually not painful, such as gentle touch or wearing glasses, trigger pain. Allodynia, although more common in migraines, was also present in some people with eTTH, which may indicate its potential influence on pain mechanisms in this condition. The study also took into account emotional factors, including depression, which can exacerbate the course and severity of complaints, highlighting the complex nature of this disease entity.

The researchers stressed that the choice of the data collection method—an online survey—may have influenced the results, but at the same time, it allowed the survey to reach a wide range of respondents, which increased the diversity of the sample. As a result, the survey provided unique data on the specifics of eTTH in the Polish population, taking into account a variety of socioeconomic factors, lifestyle, and access to medical care.

When a headache hides a bigger mystery: podcast

Click here to listen!

Diagnostic conundrums

Doctors often use CAS symptoms as a key tool to differentiate cluster headaches from other types of headaches. However, this assumption can lead to diagnostic pitfalls. Imagine a patient with episodic headaches who complains of a congested nose and runny nose — symptoms typical of CAS but also characteristic of sinusitis. Without careful analysis, the doctor may misdiagnose and implement ineffective treatment targeting the sinus infection instead of properly diagnosing the pain problem.

Dr. Straburzynski points out that the basis of diagnosis is a detailed history and tests, such as endoscopic evaluation of the nasal cavity and imaging studies of the sinuses:

"CAS are not specific to any headache, so they should not be taken as a clear indication of nasal or ocular disease" the researcher explains."The symptoms described appear to be an epiphenomenon, or secondary symptom, rather than the cause of the disease" says Dr. Straburzynski. He explains that treatment directed solely at autonomic symptoms, such as with drugs that block the autonomic system, is unlikely to be effective in treating the headache itself.

Directions for future research

One direction for further exploration of CAS is to conduct studies using patient diaries or mobile apps. Such solutions would allow real-time recording of symptoms, significantly reducing the risk of memory errors and providing more accurate data for analysis. This would better understand how often the described symptoms occur in episodic tension-type headaches and under what circumstances they occur. This, in turn, would pave the way for more precise therapeutic and diagnostic guidelines tailored to individual patients.

The long-term goal is to create more effective treatments and tools to identify CAS earlier in eTTH, which could prevent misdiagnosis and inappropriate treatment. This ambitious approach opens a new chapter in headache research, combining technology and clinical and advanced data analysis.

What does this mean for patients?

For the 1.9 billion people worldwide who experience tension-type headaches, these findings open the door to better treatment and symptom management. Recognizing CAS in episodic tension-type headaches can not only improve diagnosis but also draw attention to the need for a holistic approach to a patient's mental health, emphasizing the link between pain and emotions.

The findings of Dr. Straburzynski and Marta Waliszewska-Prosol, MD, remind us that even the most common ailments can be surprisingly complex. The study points to new perspectives in understanding and treating headaches because even mild symptoms can be part of a larger and more complicated story.

D. Sikora

FAQ: Cranial autonomic symptoms in common episodic tension headache

Do CASs only occur in migraine and other headache disorders, such as trigeminal-autonomic headaches (TACs)?

Although CAS are commonly associated with TAC and migraine, this study found that they can also occur in people with common episodic tension headache (eTTH).

How common are CAS in people with eTTH?

The study found that more than half of participants (51.8%) with eTTH reported experiencing at least one CAS during headache attacks.

Do CAS in eTTH indicate more severe headaches?

No, there was no significant difference in the intensity of headaches reported by eTTH sufferers with and without CAS. Headache frequency also did not differ between the groups.

What are the implications of the presence of CAS in eTTH?

CAS in eTTH can lead to misdiagnosis, as the symptoms may be mistaken for other conditions, such as sinusitis or conjunctivitis. This underscores the need to inform healthcare professionals that CAS can occur in eTTH.

What are cranial autonomic symptoms (CAS)?

 CAS is a group of head and facial symptoms that include:

  • tearing
  • conjunctival irritation
  • runny nose
  • nasal congestion
  • facial redness or sweating
  • drooping eyelid
  • constriction of the pupils

Do specific CASs occur more frequently in eTTH compared to migraine?

While all CAS occurred more frequently in the migraine group, only conjunctival nastiness, eyelid drooping, and pupillary constriction occurred significantly more frequently in migraines than in eTTH.

Is there an association between CAS in eTTH and allodynia or central sensitization?

The study found no association between CAS and allodynia in eTTH, suggesting that central sensitization may not play a significant role in the presence of CAS in this type of headache.

Is the presence of CAS in eTTH related to mental health?

Yes, people with eTTH who experience CAS reported higher scores on the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), a tool used to assess depression. This suggests a potential link between CAS in eTTH and depression, although further research is needed to investigate this relationship.

Dr Marcin Straburzynski is a general practitioner specialising in the treatment of headaches. He works in a small rural practice in Masuria and consults headache patients at the Headache Clinic in Warsaw. He graduated from the Medical University of Warsaw. He is the President of the Warmia and Mazury Regional Branch of the Polish College of General Practitioners.

After graduation, he was associated with the Department of Family Medicine at WUM, where he completed his PhD in the field of gut manifestations of granulomatosis with vasculitis. Currently, he works at the Department of Family Medicine and Infectious Diseases at the University of Warmia and Mazury in Olsztyn. He has authored and co-authored dozens of original papers, as well as articles and review chapters. In 2018, he completed the postgraduate Master of Headache Disorders at the University of Rome 'La Sapienza' under a scholarship from the European Headache Federation (EHF). He is the first Pole to receive this EHF endorsed certificate.

The journal "Dental and Medical Problems" is a leading dental scholarly journal in Eastern Europe founded in 1960 from the initiative of Prof. Tadeusz Owiński; it was originally called "Wrocławski Biuletyn Stomatologiczny". In 1965, the journal was renamed to "Wrocławska Stomatologia", and then the name was changed to "Dental and Medical Problems" in 2002.

"Dental and Medical Problems" is the first dentistry-profile scholarly journal in Poland and Eastern Europe in general which received a Journal Impact Factor (JIF) in the 2023 release of the Journal Citation Reports™.

"Dental and Medical Problems" is an international, peer-reviewed, open access journal covering aspects of oral sciences and general medicine, published bimonthly by Wroclaw Medical University.

Web. A. Hasiak

The material is based on the article:

Prevalence of cranial autonomic symptoms in frequent episodic tension-type headache: A post hoc analysis of the cross-sectional Migraine in Poland study

Marcin Straburzyński, Marta Waliszewska-Prosół, Magdalena Nowaczewska, Ewa Katarzyna Czapinska-Ciepiela, Anna Gryglas-Dworak, Sławomir Budrewicz

Dental and Medical Problems

doi: 10.17219/dmp/175611